CSM_RH Paper 72
Seeded MRT Pair-Correlation Audit, Fejér Frequency Localization, and the Critical Principal-Arc Floor
Project: CSM_RH
Paper: 72
Version: v0.1
Date: 2026-09-09
Campaign: 46 — SEEDED_ARITHMETIC_STRIP_GAP_GENERATION
Canonical root frontier: F-RH-017-v3
Preferred arithmetic subfrontier: F-RH-022 — AVERAGED_HARDY_LITTLEWOOD_PAIR_RESIDUAL_EXCESS
Status: EXISTING AVERAGED PRIME-PAIR PROOF AUDITED / NONCENTRAL FREQUENCIES LOCALIZED / CENTRAL ARC REMAINS CRITICAL
Canonical entry state: v1.62 / Paper 71 v0.1
RH_PROVED: FALSE
RH_DISPROVED: FALSE
GLOBAL_RH_CERTIFICATE: FALSE
Abstract
Paper 71 reduced the direct short-interval second moment to a solved local singular-series variance plus one global quantity:
the fully aggregated error of actual prime-pair correlations around the Hardy–Littlewood local prediction.
The present paper asks whether the existing averaged Hardy–Littlewood proof of Matomäki–Radziwiłł–Tao can be upgraded from arbitrary logarithmic saving to a fixed power by inserting a PESC seed.
The answer is structurally negative.
The Matomäki–Radziwiłł–Tao argument uses:
- the circle method;
- major arcs with
- short additive-frequency estimates on the minor arcs;
- a reduction to twisted Dirichlet-polynomial mean values;
- Heath–Brown decomposition into Type II and Type components.
The difficult Type and Type estimates contain genuine polynomial margins at several internal stages. For example, a hard Type contribution is reduced to an error carrying an explicit factor
Thus the final formulation should not be interpreted as saying that every noncentral analytic component is intrinsically logarithmic.
However, none of those improvements resolves the root obstruction.
Let
on a dyadic block and define
Let
The Fejér-type weight
is the natural frequency weight associated with averaging prime-pair correlations over two shifts or with the corresponding full convolution energy.
It obeys
This weight radically changes the importance of the rational arcs.
For a nonzero reduced rational
and
one has, for large ,
Hence
The nonprincipal polylogarithmic major arcs therefore carry only polylogarithmic Fejér weight rather than the full weight.
After the Hardy–Littlewood local main terms are extracted, the standard Siegel–Walfisz major-arc approximation error
contributes only
to the weighted quadratic energy, for arbitrarily large fixed .
Relative to
this is a fixed-power saving
Thus the low-conductor nonprincipal major-arc approximation errors which were a serious issue for the shifted-Möbius auxiliary route are not the root obstruction in the Fejér-weighted prime-pair aggregate.
The central arc is completely different.
Assume PESC and set
Then
Partial summation gives, uniformly for
For
and
Therefore the PESC seed yields only
This is exactly the critical F-RH-022 scale.
A smooth boundary mode
has
through a fixed positive fraction of the central interval
Thus the critical central-arc scale is saturated by the canonical boundary model.
Consequently:
PESC fixed strip
+
existing averaged-prime-pair minor-arc machinery
cannot yield
unless it proves new cancellation on the central principal arc itself.
This conclusion is stronger than saying that the Matomäki–Radziwiłł–Tao theorem currently has only logarithmic error terms. The hard Type minor-arc technology may be improved substantially without touching the root boundary mode.
A second elementary frequency localization reinforces this point.
By Parseval,
On the region
Therefore
Relative to , this has saving exponent
Hence every frequency satisfying
is automatically supercritical:
The possible PESC boundary obstruction is confined to the low additive-frequency band
The central arc lies inside this band and already saturates the seed exponent.
Finally, a classical Selberg-integral estimate gives a useful conditional calibration. If
and one supplements the fixed zero-free strip by the Density Hypothesis, then the standard estimate is
For
this becomes
The corresponding saving exponent
is strictly smaller than the seed exponent whenever .
Thus even a fixed strip plus the classical density-level zero input does not self-amplify the seed through the Selberg integral.
The missing ingredient is a genuine pair-cancellation theorem, arithmetically represented by F-RH-022 and spectrally represented by cancellation among the low-frequency zero ensemble.
The canonical next track is therefore:
PAIR5
PRINCIPAL-ARC / LOW-FREQUENCY PAIR-CANCELLATION EXCESS
not another improvement to the noncentral Type machinery.
No RH theorem is claimed.
1. Entry state
Assume
Set
Paper 71 opened F-RH-022:
with the strict amplifier requirement
The question of this paper is whether this can be obtained by inserting the seed into the existing averaged Hardy–Littlewood proof.
2. MRT proof architecture
Matomäki, Radziwiłł and Tao prove an averaged Hardy–Littlewood theorem for
Their circle-method decomposition uses major arcs
and minor arcs elsewhere.
The major arcs are evaluated by classical prime exponential-sum asymptotics.
The minor arcs are reduced to local additive-frequency estimates of the form
A Fourier/logarithmic change of variables reduces those estimates to mean values of twisted Dirichlet polynomials.
For , Heath–Brown decomposition produces:
- Type II;
- Type ;
- Type ;
- Type ;
- Type .
The Type and pieces are the principal innovations responsible for lowering the shift exponent below .
3. The logarithmic statement does not mean every inner estimate is logarithmic
The published minor-arc proposition is
However, inside the Type proof, after Jutila's medium-interval fourth moment estimate and the averaged exponential-sum estimate, a hard contribution is bounded by a term containing
Likewise, the Type treatment uses a classical exponent pair and has a genuine polynomial margin in the admissible shift range.
Therefore it is incorrect to identify the final arbitrary-log theorem with an intrinsic absence of power in every noncentral component.
Record:
B-RH-104
MRT_HARD_TYPE_D3_D4_ANALYSIS_CONTAINS_INTERNAL_FIXED_POWER_MARGIN
CERTIFIED_AS_PROOF_AUDIT
This fact does not imply that the complete prime-pair theorem has a power-saving error.
4. Fejér weight associated with the pair aggregate
Let
and
Let
The standard identity is
The quadratic form
is the exact Fourier energy of the corresponding full convolution and is the natural frequency model for the triangularly aggregated pair correlations.
Only this frequency weighting is used in the barrier calculations below.
Sharp endpoint versions of the root energy require standard boundary bookkeeping; no new RH implication in this paper depends on discarding those endpoints.
5. Polylogarithmic nonprincipal major arcs are Fejér-small
Let
and
For sufficiently large ,
Therefore
Suppose the major-arc prime approximation has residual
Then summing the residual square over all polylogarithmic nonprincipal major arcs gives
for every prescribed fixed , after choosing sufficiently large.
The cross term between the local main term and obeys the same conclusion after enlarging .
Since
the relative exponent of this error is
For the F-RH-022 amplifier range
this is strictly larger than .
Record:
B-RH-105
FEJER_WEIGHT_MAKES_POLYLOG_NONPRINCIPAL_MAJOR_ARC_APPROXIMATION_ERRORS_SUPERCRITICAL
CERTIFIED
The local main terms themselves are not discarded; they are precisely what reconstruct the singular-series contribution already extracted in Paper 71.
6. Seeded principal exponential sum
Let
PESC gives
By partial summation,
Hence, uniformly for
Record:
B-RH-106
PESC_SEED_CONTROLS_THE_Q1_ULTRAMAJOR_PRIME_ERROR_AT_N_TO_ONE_MINUS_D
CERTIFIED
7. The central principal-arc critical floor
Fix a sufficiently small constant
If
and
then
Therefore
Combining with Section 6 gives the seed-level central energy bound
Since
this is
There is no fixed excess beyond the seed exponent.
Create:
O-RH-163
Q1_CENTRAL_PRINCIPAL_ARC_HAS_A_SEED_CRITICAL_ENERGY_FLOOR_AT_EXPONENT_KAPPA
CERTIFIED_AS_METHOD_BARRIER
The word "floor" refers to the method scale: PESC alone gives no stronger upper exponent.
8. Smooth boundary mode saturates the central scale
Let
and model the boundary coefficient density by
up to a harmless nonzero constant.
Then
Rescale
Riemann-sum approximation gives
locally uniformly in .
The limiting integral is nonzero at and hence on a sufficiently small interval
Therefore
on a fixed positive fraction of
Consequently its central weighted energy is
Thus O-RH-163 is sharp in the canonical boundary model.
9. Parseval localizes all possible supercritical difficulty to low frequency
Parseval gives
Fix
On
Therefore:
Theorem 9.1 — Far-frequency automatic power saving
Relative to
the saving exponent is
Thus the far-frequency sector is already stronger than the PESC seed whenever
Equivalently, any possible seed-critical obstruction is confined to
Record:
B-RH-107
PARSEVAL_CONFINES_ALL_SEED_CRITICAL_PAIR_ENERGY_TO_AN_ULTRALOW_ADDITIVE_FREQUENCY_BAND
CERTIFIED
10. Consequence for the MRT minor-arc attack
The Matomäki–Radziwiłł–Tao proof invests its deepest work in noncentral minor arcs:
- Type ;
- Type ;
- twisted Dirichlet-polynomial mean values;
- medium-interval fourth moments;
- exponential-sum estimates.
These tools are essential for obtaining the almost-all Hardy–Littlewood theorem in the range
But for the seeded F-RH-022 amplifier they are not, by themselves, the decisive missing input.
Even a hypothetical theorem that made every noncentral minor-arc contribution negligible would leave the central arc at
Hence:
O-RH-164
PERFECT_NONCENTRAL_MRT_MINOR_ARC_CONTROL_CANNOT_AMPLIFY_WHILE_Q1_CENTRAL_ARC_REMAINS_AT_SEED_SCALE
CERTIFIED
This is the pair-correlation analogue of Paper 63's long-anchor barrier.
11. Conditional fixed-strip Selberg calibration
Let
Zaccagnini records the classical estimate, assuming the Density Hypothesis for simplicity,
Set
and
Then
Since
the fixed-strip Selberg saving exponent is
For every fixed
Thus a fixed strip, even combined with the classical density-level input, is not a self-amplifier.
Record as conditional calibration:
O-RH-165
FIXED_STRIP_PLUS_DENSITY_HYPOTHESIS_SELBerg_BOUND_HAS_SUBCRITICAL_SAVING_KAPPA_TIMES_ONE_MINUS_TAU
CONDITIONAL_METHOD_CALIBRATION
No Density Hypothesis is assumed anywhere else in the campaign.
12. What the existing averaged pair theorem can and cannot contribute
The existing theorem proves
for all but
shifts in the established range.
This is strong enough to show that most individual pair errors are logarithmically small.
It does not improve the central PNT boundary mode supplied by PESC.
The seed, conversely, improves the global error to a fixed power but only at exactly the critical exponent.
Therefore the two inputs meet at the boundary without producing an excess.
13. Revised status of F-RH-022
F-RH-022 remains mathematically correct as a sufficient root subfrontier:
activates the Paper-54 amplifier.
But the naive strategy
take the existing MRT averaged prime-pair proof
and replace its zeta zero-free input by PESC
is closed.
The seed only controls the principal central arc at the critical scale.
Any successful proof of F-RH-022 must add information which creates cancellation inside the low-frequency principal sector, not merely on the existing minor arcs.
14. New active subtrack
Open:
PAIR5
PRINCIPAL_ARC_LOW_FREQUENCY_PAIR_CANCELLATION_EXCESS
Target form:
prove a fixed excess beyond
for the low-frequency contribution of the actual prime error after the Hardy–Littlewood local main term is extracted.
Equivalent arithmetic language:
prove fixed-power aggregate cancellation in
Equivalent spectral language:
prove pair decorrelation of the low-frequency zero ensemble beyond what follows from the location of the rightmost zero alone.
This is exactly the new information absent from the seed strip.
15. External proof audit
Matomäki–Radziwiłł–Tao's paper records:
- major arcs with denominators ;
- a Siegel–Walfisz prime major-arc approximation;
- minor-arc local savings of arbitrary log power;
- reduction to twisted Dirichlet polynomials;
- Type II and Type decomposition;
- Type analysis using Jutila's fourth moment and Robert–Sargos exponential-sum estimates;
- Type analysis using an mean value theorem and a van der Corput exponent pair.
Their proof explicitly contains polynomial margins in hard Type subcases while the final proposition is stated with logarithmic saving.
The proof therefore supports the distinction made here between:
noncentral analytic savings
and
central principal-boundary cancellation.
16. State transition
Advance candidate state
Add:
B-RH-104
MRT_HARD_TYPE_D3_D4_ANALYSIS_CONTAINS_INTERNAL_FIXED_POWER_MARGIN
CERTIFIED_AS_PROOF_AUDIT
B-RH-105
FEJER_WEIGHT_MAKES_POLYLOG_NONPRINCIPAL_MAJOR_ARC_APPROXIMATION_ERRORS_SUPERCRITICAL
CERTIFIED
B-RH-106
PESC_SEED_CONTROLS_THE_Q1_ULTRAMAJOR_PRIME_ERROR_AT_N_TO_ONE_MINUS_D
CERTIFIED
B-RH-107
PARSEVAL_CONFINES_ALL_SEED_CRITICAL_PAIR_ENERGY_TO_AN_ULTRALOW_ADDITIVE_FREQUENCY_BAND
CERTIFIED
O-RH-163
Q1_CENTRAL_PRINCIPAL_ARC_HAS_A_SEED_CRITICAL_ENERGY_FLOOR_AT_EXPONENT_KAPPA
CERTIFIED_AS_METHOD_BARRIER
O-RH-164
PERFECT_NONCENTRAL_MRT_MINOR_ARC_CONTROL_CANNOT_AMPLIFY_WHILE_Q1_CENTRAL_ARC_REMAINS_AT_SEED_SCALE
CERTIFIED
O-RH-165
FIXED_STRIP_PLUS_DENSITY_HYPOTHESIS_SELBerg_BOUND_HAS_SUBCRITICAL_SAVING_KAPPA_TIMES_ONE_MINUS_TAU
CONDITIONAL_METHOD_CALIBRATION
Open:
PAIR5
PRINCIPAL_ARC_LOW_FREQUENCY_PAIR_CANCELLATION_EXCESS
ACTIVE
No RH certificate is created.
17. Conclusion
The averaged Hardy–Littlewood proof does not fail because every part of its minor-arc machinery is only logarithmic.
Some of its hardest components already possess fixed-power internal slack.
The PESC amplifier fails for a more fundamental reason.
The central principal arc contains the seed boundary mode itself.
PESC controls that arc at exactly
and the canonical smooth boundary mode saturates the scale.
All improvements outside that central sector can leave the boundary untouched.
Therefore F-RH-022 cannot be obtained by a naive seed insertion into the existing averaged-prime-pair proof.
The next new information must be pair cancellation at the principal low frequency itself.
That is PAIR5.